Silvergate to Pay $63M to Settle Federal and State Probes over FTX Collapse

by

As a seasoned crypto investor who has weathered through the ups and downs of this volatile market, I cannot help but feel a sense of unease upon learning about Silvergate’s $63 million settlement with regulators. The allegations of negligence-based fraud, oversight failures, and suspicious transactions are concerning to say the least.

After the significant cryptocurrency market collapses in 2022 and 2023, Silvergate, a California lender deeply involved with crypto, reached a substantial agreement with regulatory bodies. On July 2, 2024, the Federal Reserve, the California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (DFPI), and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) jointly announced a $63 million penalty against Silvergate Capital Corp., the parent company of Silvergate. This fine concludes probes into Silvergate’s compliance procedures, focusing on its interactions with the defunct crypto exchange FTX. The settlement also enables Silvergate to formally relinquish its banking license, thereby completing its bankruptcy proceedings initiated in 2023.

Silvergate’s $50M SEC Settlement

Silvergate reached an agreement with regulatory authorities without acknowledging the validity of their allegations. The terms of this settlement raise red flags. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) levied a $50 million fine against the bank for suspected negligent misrepresentation. According to the SEC, Silvergate deceived investors regarding compliance matters and failed to report suspicious transactions.

Gurbir Grewall, the SEC’s Enforcement Director, stated that Silvergate did not identify approximately $9 billion worth of questionable transactions between FTX and its related entities. Such a lapse indicates a significant flaw in their monitoring system, potentially enabling illicit activities to slip through unchecked.

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) imposed penalties on former Silvergate executives as well. Alan Lane, the CEO, is required to pay $1 million, while Kathleen Fraher, the COO, must pay $250,000. Additionally, the SEC alleges that Antonio Martino, the former CFO, underreported losses and falsified Silvergate’s financial statements. However, Martino disputes these claims, asserting it was due to a “subjectively interpreted” accounting method and that he acted in good faith.

Silvergate’s Role in FTX Scandal

As a crypto investor, I’ve noticed that the settlement announcement between Silvergate and FTX fails to address the ongoing criminal investigation by the Justice Department into Silvergate’s relationship with FTX and its founder Sam Bankman-Fried. Previously, law enforcement suggested that Silvergate could have been a victim of fraud perpetrated by FTX. This raises some concerns for me about Silvergate’s involvement in the FTX scandal. Was the bank unwittingly deceived by a complex scheme, or did lax oversight enable FTX’s alleged misconduct?

The demise of FTX underlines the risks inherent in the cryptocurrency sector, and Silvergate’s $63 million settlement is a cautionary tale for conventional financial institutions pondering entry into this volatile market. As regulators intensify their scrutiny of crypto, robust compliance practices and healthy doses of skepticism are indispensable prerequisites for any bank contemplating involvement with digital assets.

Read More

2024-07-02 14:15