Stranger Things: The First Shadow Reviews Praise the Horrifying Origin on Broadway

Critics have shared their thoughts on the initial performances of “Stranger Things: The First Shadow” on Broadway. This highly anticipated play first hit the stage at London’s Phoenix Theatre back in December 2023. A remarkable ensemble of actors like Louis McCartney, Gabrielle Nevaeh, T.R. Knight, Alex Breaux, and Rosie Benton are part of an impressive lineup in this production.

Stranger Things: The First Shadow reviews call it a ‘Triumph on Broadway’

As a dedicated fan, I’ve had the privilege to delve into the captivating world of Stranger Things with “Stranger Things: The First Shadow,” a play penned by the talented Kate Trefry. This gripping tale takes us on an intriguing journey, offering insights into the life of Henry Creel before the series’ events unfold, all while staying true to the original narrative crafted by the Duffer Brothers and Jack Thorne, and skillfully directed by Stephen Daldry.

Here is what critics are saying about the play:

Kyle Turner from New York Theatre Guide stated that “Stranger Things: The First Shadow” is a show with a lot going on. It combines elements of possession horror, family drama, high school comedy-drama, Cold War suspense, and haunted house terror, swiftly shifting between tones from one scene to the next. What’s remarkable about it is its grand scale, and while it never becomes dull, it doesn’t always deliver on a technical or dramatic level.

Greg Evans from Deadline notes that Stranger Things: The First Shadow exceeds previous Broadway productions like Grey House and King Kong in terms of startling moments and authentic chills. He wrote, “Broadway doesn’t often deliver the frightening; however, there was the eerie Grey House a few seasons past, and when King Kong stomped about on stage, but Stranger Things: The First Shadow surpasses them significantly in jump scares and genuine thrills.

Kobi Kassal from Theaterly declared that the play was a “Triumphant Success” on Broadway. Kassal explained, “Stranger Things: The First Shadow presents an extraordinary and awe-inspiring display that surpasses any previously witnessed on Broadway.

According to Emlyn Travis from Entertainment Weeky, this play offers an intense, engaging experience that seamlessly takes viewers into the world of their favorite TV show. It achieves this through breathtaking special effects, meticulously designed sets, and powerful acting performances.

Chris Jones from the New York Daily News stated, “The live (largely) Stranger Things on Broadway likely represents the pinnacle of TV and stage fusion. Anyone who cherishes Broadway’s creativity and uniqueness might have found themselves overwhelmed with admiration for the highly successful streaming service whose popularity continues to soar, even during a challenging time for the stock market.

Read More

2025-04-23 17:12