New Superman Movie Draws Mixed Early Criticism

by

Before the global release on July 11, a privileged few – film critics and movie industry professionals – have already had a sneak peek at the new cinematic revival of the Man of Steel. Early feedback presents a mixed view.

A Colorful, Political Take On A Classic Hero

Many people find Gunn’s vision a refreshing change from the growing predictability of superhero blockbusters. GQ Senior Editor Frazier Tharpe hailed the movie as “one of the most unique superhero films in a while,” commending its vibrant aesthetics, playful mood, and shamelessly fantastical aspects – ranging from floating orbs, colossal beasts, to Superman’s trusted canine companion, Krypto the Superdog.

The heart of the film’s emotional depth lies in a late speech given by Clark Kent (David Corenswet), which, according to Tharpe, perfectly summarizes Gunn’s idea: a sincere, optimistic hero who embodies goodness and empathy, rather than the gloomy, brooding characters that have been prevalent in recent DC productions. Tharpe pointed out, hinting at 2013’s Man of Steel, that there will be no such controversial neck-snapping scenes here.

The story, set in fictional lands Boravia and Jarhanpur, has been praised for integrating political themes into its narrative, offering both thrilling action and insightful commentary on real-life conflicts. According to the New York Times’ Alissa Wilkinson, her initial “fatigue with superhero stories” transformed into admiration for the movie’s genuine, occasionally quirky appeal. Meanwhile, Alison Willmore from Vulture pointed out the film’s connection to Superman’s original creators, who were Jewish American men, and noted that their hero – an immigrant and outsider – has always carried political undertones.

Critical Praise: Heart, Humor, and Humanity

The initial Rotten Tomatoes rating for the film is a heartening 86%, indicating that numerous critics found it engaging despite any reservations they might have had. As stated by Associated Press critic Jake Coyle, the movie feels remarkably human amidst today’s production-line style of superhero films. In his view, Gunn’s unique approach helps rekindle the sense of awe and idealism that initially made Superman a significant cultural symbol.

Critic Owen Gleiberman from Variety rated Superman as an outstanding entry in its genre, on par with films like Batman Begins and Iron Man. He praised James Gunn for skillfully combining epic action scenes with personal emotions, although he noted that the movie sometimes had trouble taking a moment to pause and reflect.

In a unique and heartwarming manner, Superman embodies his comic book origins more vividly than I ever imagined, overflowing with such warmth that it’s impossible not to be enamored. A masterfully crafted tale that deftly combines various elements, featuring an exceptional cast and groundbreaking action sequences that push the boundaries of creativity. The future of the DC Universe promises EXCELLENCE!

— Jack (-_) (@captaincupkicks) July 9, 2025

The Kryptonite: Cluttered Plot and Divisive Performances

While many found appreciation for the movie, others remained unconvinced. Critics particularly noticed issues with the film’s disorganized narrative flow and inconsistent character development. Peter Bradshaw from The Guardian delivered one of the most severe criticisms, describing Corenswet’s portrayal of Superman as “devoid of soul” and bemoaning a “superfluous and overcrowded new origin story” that weakens the hero’s emotional resonance.

As a gamer diving into this superhero saga, I found myself grappling with a plot that was needlessly complex and, at times, borderline confusing. The tone shifts felt inconsistent, never quite finding its footing. Despite the captivating spectacle, it was Corenswet’s performance that truly left me spellbound, showcasing an incredible screen presence. Unfortunately, Hoult’s talent was underutilized in this narrative.

— Josh Parham (@JRParham) July 8, 2025

The secondary characters drew a variety of responses. Rachel Brosnahan’s portrayal of Lois Lane was highly commended for its wit and intelligence, while Nicholas Hoult’s Lex Luthor was criticized by some as being more annoying than menacing. Interestingly, Krypto the Superdog turned out to be a surprising scene-stealer, with at least one reviewer suggesting they’d prefer an entire film dedicated to him over the main characters.

Gunn’s Long Game

Regarding James Gunn’s own stance, he appears unruffled by the mixed reactions. In candid interviews, Gunn downplayed worries about Superman potentially being labeled a flop if it doesn’t outdo Man of Steel’s $700 million global revenue. Instead, he presented the film as the initial chapter in a broader artistic plan – titled “Chapter One: Gods and Monsters” – designed to reimagine the DC cinematic universe over the subsequent decade.

Fans expecting an immediate masterpiece might need to adjust their thoughts, however, Gunn’s dedication towards crafting emotional, unique stories within the superhero genre seems genuine. Whether viewers will appreciate this fresh take on Clark Kent or yearn for the traditional caped heroes isn’t known yet. For now, Superman serves as a testament that even in an era of massive blockbusters, a hero dressed in red and blue can continue to provoke discussion and bring joy. And maybe, that ability to stir up conversation is a kind of superpower by itself.

Read More

2025-07-09 21:10