Madden NFL 25 review: Stretching the field

Madden NFL 25 review: Stretching the field

As a lifelong Madden fanatic who’s been through the highs and lows of gridiron gaming, I must admit that Madden NFL 25 left me feeling a bit like a seasoned quarterback handed a wet noodle instead of a football. The gameplay tweaks were intriguing, but the hit-stick timing felt more like a minefield than the thrill of a tackle.


As an avid sports enthusiast, I couldn’t help but feel excited about the revival of EA’s College Football series this summer, stealing the spotlight in the world of sports games. My curiosity was piqued when it came to Madden, a series that seems to have strayed from its path during the contemporary era. With Madden NFL 25, EA Sports has chosen to focus on enhancing the game’s presentation and visual aesthetics, yet it’s evident that Madden now ranks as the second-best ongoing American Football simulator in today’s market.

Trying to bring the boom

Madden NFL 25 review: Stretching the field

As a dedicated gamer, I can’t help but notice the buzz surrounding the revamped Hit Stick in Madden NFL 25. This legendary feature has taken a new angle now – it’s timing-based! The outcome of each hit depends on whether you press the Hit Stick too early, just right, or a bit late. Apart from player ratings and attributes, there’s real-time feedback to let you know where you stand in terms of timing. It’s an exciting twist that adds another layer of strategy to the gameplay!

If your Hit Stick timing is off, the opposing player has a greater chance of slipping past the tackle. Some impressive animations display a Running Back or Wide Receiver shaking off a strong hit, regaining their footing, and continuing their run downfield. However, it can be quite frustrating when a skilled defender fails to make a tackle on a weaker offensive player due to an early or late trigger of the Hit Stick. Despite being an interesting addition, I wouldn’t mind if EA opted not to include these changes in next year’s version.

In addition, Madden has been updated with several gameplay adjustments to match EA Sports College Football 25, including a revamped two-phase kicking system and alterations to Read Option plays where holding A/X makes the quarterback retain the ball. These modifications should please hardcore fans of both games due to their similarities.

Beyond this, the gameplay in Madden feels largely similar to previous versions. It’s satisfactory, although I did spot a few new ball-carrier movements. However, there are instances where player models collide strangely and disrupt the smooth flow of the game. If you’re a seasoned Madden player, you know what to expect.

New season, new look

Madden NFL 25 review: Stretching the field

Presentation updates were clearly a key priority with Madden NFL 25. EA has finally added two new broadcast teams with Greg Olsen/Mike Tirico and Kate Scott/Brock Huard. I’ve got nothing against Brandon Gaudin and Charles Davis, but we were desperately in need of some new voices in the booth.

These changes extend to the game intros and the score bug, which have solid refreshes from last year. The new home screen is completely devoid of style, with a vertical menu list accompanied by footage from real NFL games last year.

To the big leagues

Madden NFL 25 review: Stretching the field

As a die-hard fan, I’m thrilled about the return of College Football games, and Madden NFL 25 has made my day by reintroducing an exciting retro feature – the Superstar mode that lets me transition my college player to the NFL. With Madden NFL 25, I could seamlessly import my Iowa QB from CFB 25, retaining my unique look while still having the chance to fine-tune my attributes for my NFL adventure. Following a successful Combine performance, I was honored with being drafted in the first round by the New York Jets. Now, after guiding Iowa to a National Championship, I’m challenged with revitalizing one of professional football’s most tumultuous teams.

In this very moment, I experienced the sheer enjoyment that Madden has to offer. This year’s version introduces an engaging draft scene where my character strides onto the stage, shakes hands with Commissioner Roger Goodell, and we both proudly display our jerseys. Immersed in the football universe like never before, I found myself deeply invested in watching my player’s career unfold.

As a long-time gamer who has spent countless hours immersed in sports video games, I can confidently say that the latest update to Franchise mode is a game-changer for me. The revamped User Interface (UI) for draft night is a breath of fresh air and makes it effortless to scrutinize potential prospects and make well-informed decisions. Compared to previous years, this is by far the most significant improvement to Franchise mode I’ve encountered. It simplifies the process and streamlines my gameplay experience significantly. While Superstar might have some new draft features, nothing compares to the seamless and intuitive interface in Franchise mode this year.

Madden NFL 25 introduces a female coach for the first time, which is fantastic! Additionally, EA has updated the Super Bowl celebration, a welcome change after it was used repetitively in previous games. However, the player upgrade/ability interface remains unchanged, as well as the Weekly Strategy process. Unfortunately, the lack of new features compared to College Football 25’s Dynasty mode was disappointing.

As a devoted fan, I can’t help but rave about Madden’s Ultimate Team – it’s like being a kid in a candy store for NFL enthusiasts! In this captivating game mode, you gather players spanning NFL history through pack openings. However, it’s disheartening to see that the thrill of playing as legendary NFL figures remains confined to a carefully orchestrated experience primarily designed to encourage continuous spending.

Timeout

Madden NFL 25 review: Stretching the field

In a less formal way, here’s how you could rephrase it: The NFL is known for being a stuffy and business-oriented football league (often called the No Fun League), compared to college football. I see a similar pattern emerging between Madden NFL and College Football video games. While I appreciate some updates in Madden 25, the game feels flat and unexciting. There’s nothing innovative or exciting about it that I can share with my friends. The core modes haven’t changed much from last year, except for a few Superstar modifications. The main menu even looks more like an investor information page than a video game interface.

Madden NFL 25 isn’t a poor game; instead, it’s just another minor adjustment of the same game I’ve been playing for the past five years. I’ve come to accept that contemporary Madden games won’t be exceptional until there’s a significant shift in the approach they’re made and marketed, but at least I can revisit College Football in the meantime.

Read More

2024-08-21 22:28