Jacob Elordi’s Wuthering Heights casting controversy explained

by

Jacob Elordi's Wuthering Heights casting controversy explained

As a gamer who has spent countless hours immersed in the rich tapestry of stories and characters that literature offers, I find myself deeply invested in the ongoing debate surrounding the casting of Jacob Elordi as Heathcliff in Emerald Fennell’s upcoming adaptation of Wuthering Heights.

The choice by Emerald Fennell to cast Jacob Elordi as Heathcliff in her upcoming adaptation of Wuthering Heights has led to much discussion in the United Kingdom. As reported by Deadline, Elordi and Margot Robbie will play Heathcliff and Catherine Earnshaw respectively, while Fennell will handle writing, directing, and producing duties for this project. Filming is scheduled to start in the UK next year.

The ethnicity of Heathcliff, a character from Emily Brontë’s 1847 novel, has been a subject of debate. He is portrayed as a “dark-skinned gypsy” and was found abandoned at Liverpool’s slave port. As a result, many readers assume that Heathcliff might not be of white descent. This racial uncertainty isn’t trivial; it significantly shapes his narrative, leading to his mistreatment and position as an outcast. Considering the scarcity of ethnic minority representation in media, casting a white actor for this multifaceted character could overlook a potential opportunity to represent diverse characters more accurately.

Michael Stewart, head of the Brontë Writing Centre, made this observation to The Daily Telegraph: “For a long time, white actors have portrayed the ethnically ambiguous character in ‘Wuthering Heights.’ However, times have changed, and today, when we depict people in art and culture, there’s a newfound sense of accountability that wasn’t present 20 years ago. This is particularly true when the character’s identity plays a crucial role in their story.” And he’s correct; our cultural landscape has evolved significantly, and it’s increasingly important to cast actors who embody the character’s true identity when it’s so integral to their narrative.

Historically, Heathcliff has typically been played by white actors, such as Tom Hardy in the 2009 ITV adaptation. However, Andrea Arnold’s 2011 film challenged this norm by choosing James Howson, an actor of Black descent, to embody the character. This casting shift added fresh perspectives to Heathcliff’s portrayal as an outsider and how he is viewed within the narrative by other characters.

As an ardent admirer, I echo the sentiments expressed by Dr. Claire O’Callaghan, the distinguished editor-in-chief of the Brontë Society’s official journal. She voiced her concern about casting a white actor for Heathcliff in Wuthering Heights, stating that such a choice overlooks the inherent ambiguity that adds depth to his character.

The response to the social media announcement has been quite strong, with numerous individuals expressing concern that the selection might lessen Heathcliff’s character’s potency. A widely shared post noted, “Heathcliff is portrayed as a dark-skinned man in the novel and a significant aspect involves him experiencing racial prejudice from his adopted family. However, it seems Jacob Elordi is just right for the part!” Critics such as Clarisse Loughrey have even questioned whether the book was thoroughly read before making this decision, while others like Gavia Baker-Whitelaw have pointed out that the casting appears to prioritize an Instagram-friendly image over staying true to the original work.

Wuthering Heights goes beyond being merely a heart-wrenching love tale; it’s a layered narrative encompassing social stratification, passion, and vengeance, unfolding against the rugged landscapes of the English moors. The mysterious origins and prejudice faced by Heathcliff significantly shape his personality and the novel’s underlying messages. Choosing an actor like Elordi, who is white, might diminish some of the story’s depth and hinder a more profound exploration of these themes.

Fennell’s group is yet to address the criticism, however, it’s evident that the choice of casting has ignited a wider discussion on truthfulness in narrative creation and the importance of careful representation in movie and television productions.

Read More

2024-09-28 19:14