Dateline Unforgettable: Where Are Thad Reynolds’ Killers Now?

Dateline Unforgettable: Where Are Thad Reynolds’ Killers Now?

As a true crime enthusiast and follower of Dateline: Unforgettable, I am eagerly anticipating this week’s episode featuring the tragic and shocking story of Thad Reynolds’ murder. The gruesome details of his death in July 2004, as reported by various media outlets at that time, left me utterly stunned.


I was deeply disturbed when I heard about the shocking murder case that took place in northwest Georgia back in July 2004. The victim, Thad Reynolds, was found dead outside his workplace with multiple stab wounds. According to some reports, the attacker struck after Thad had arrived at the distribution center where he worked. Two individuals were later arrested for the heinous crime – Thad’s wife, Michelle Reynolds, and Pastor Scott Harper. This intriguing and gruesome case is set to be featured in this week’s episode of Dateline: Unforgettable. Don’t miss it on Thursday, July 25, at 8 p.m. ET.

Based on WSB-TV’s report, Michelle Reynolds and Scott Harper were apprehended by authorities not long after Thad Reynolds was brutally stabbed 19 times. The Rome News-Tribune mentioned that the assailant attacked Thad when he was near his car. Authorities found a hunting knife sheath next to Reynold’s vehicle at the crime scene. Additionally, a witness claimed they spotted a red minivan departing from the area around the time of the incident.

According to the reports from WSB-TV and WFMY News, Reynolds’ wife, Michelle, is said to have had an affair with Harper at the church they attended together. The two allegedly started a secretive relationship that led them to plot Thad Reynolds’ murder. While the details of their communication methods vary between accounts, in October 2008, Harper confessed to the crime and accepted a plea deal to avoid capital punishment. In January 2010, Michelle also admitted her involvement in the case and pleaded guilty. Currently, both accused individuals are serving their prison sentences for this crime in Georgia’s correctional facilities.

Thad Reynolds’ Killers: Where are Michelle Reynolds and Scott Harper now?

Previously brought up, Michelle Reynolds and Scott Harper were given penalties for their offenses. A different article by The Rome News-Tribune stated that the former clergyman confessed to felony murder, severe battery, and premeditated murder. Consequently, the judge ordered him to spend the rest of his life in prison without any chance of parole. Currently, Scott Harper is incarcerated at Phillips State Prison in Georgia.

At the same time, Michelle Reynolds, wife of Thad Reynolds, admitted guilt for voluntary manslaughter as reported by AJC. Subsequently, the court ordered a 20-year prison term for her. Presently, Michelle Reynolds is incarcerated at Pulaski State Prison in Georgia.

As a devoted fan of Dateline: Unforgettable, I’m thrilled to share that this week’s episode will be all about the intriguing case of Thad Reynolds. Mark your calendars, fellow enthusiasts, as we’ll delve into the mystery on July 25! The suspense is already building up inside me, and I can hardly wait to see how this unfolds. Stay tuned!

Read More

2024-07-25 17:10