Willie Nelson’s Red Headed Stranger turns 50

by

By 1973, Willie Nelson had already released 15 country albums, but they didn’t garner significant success. Although people acknowledged him as an exceptional songwriter, he wasn’t the typical polished Country music artist. He was somewhat unconventional in appearance, with a thin voice. Despite adhering to Nashville norms for most of his career, it’s clear that there was a rebellious spirit within him.

Initially, he started showing his rebellious side when he switched from RCA to Atlantic. First up was “Shotgun Willie,” which significantly contrasted with his former polished image. Following that, he released “Phases and Stages,” an album that was thematic in nature. For this project, Willie decided to completely part ways with Nashville and instead recorded it in Muscle Shoals.

In essence, they both achieved a fair level of achievement, with their performances on the country charts being roughly equivalent to the sales of their final RCA albums. Additionally, if someone took notice, they would discover that the Atlantic albums managed to sneak into the lower echelons of the pop chart too.

An iconic Willie Nelson album is about to reach a milestone

Atlantic wasn’t indifferent; they believed they were signing an established artist to spearhead their venture into the country music industry. However, the two albums he produced for them didn’t meet that objective. Ultimately, Atlantic decided not only to discontinue working with Willie, but also to abandon their initial efforts to break into the country market.

At CBS/Columbia, they closely monitored the situation. With assistance from his close friend Waylon Jennings, who had numerous country hits in the early ’70s for RCA, Willie secured a fresh deal with Columbia that provided him full creative control. Subsequently, he journeyed to Garland, Texas, to record his debut album under this new agreement.

Nelson explained that he selected Autumn Sound in Garland for its secluded location, distancing himself from any recording company executives. He desired freedom from Columbia’s influence, avoiding their experienced session musicians supporting him. He preferred his latest album to maintain a raw, unpolished charm.

Willie assembled his road group, known as The Family, to Autumn for some recording sessions. Mickey Raphael provided harmonica, while Paul English and his brother, Billy, took care of the drumming duties. Bee Spears manned the bass, Jody Payne handled both guitar and mandolin, and Bucky Meadows filled in wherever necessary, including playing the piano – a role usually filled by Willie’s sister, Bobbie, on this occasion.

The tunes they were spinning represented somewhat of a shift, even compared to Willie’s last two albums. Similar to the album “Shotgun Willie“, the new one retained an authentic, unpolished vibe. In a way reminiscent of “Phases and Stages“, it also followed a broader narrative structure.

The album was themed around the dissolution of a marriage. However, the fresh content delved deeper. While still inspired by a failed romance, it explored the history, current state, and potential outcomes of a separation, all within the backdrop of the American Old West.

Back in the day, I’ve always been a fan of Willie Nelson’s music, so you can imagine my excitement when he shared that he’d penned some fresh tunes for his upcoming album. Among those new tracks, there were some old-time country gems that resonated deeply with me, songs from my childhood days. One such piece, penned by Carl Lutz and Edith Lindeman, was a heartrending tale of a solitary man, a vanished love, and a crime. It was called “Red Headed Stranger,” and its poignant narrative ended up being the perfect fit for the album’s title.

The album titled “Red Headed Stranger” contains a total of 15 songs, yet only three of them exceed the three-minute mark. Some tracks are even shorter than 90 seconds, such as the frequently occurring “Time of the Preacher Theme,” which functions as a connecting element between different songs.

Nelson has the ability to convey more in a single minute than most songwriters can express over five minutes. For instance, the second side of “Red Headed Stranger” begins with one of his brief compositions – “Denver”. This quick piece encapsulates the lingering loneliness that dominates the entire album and manages to tell a full story in only 53 seconds.

On the final track of the album titled “Bandera,” Willie expressed that poignant sadness without needing lyrics. The beautiful finale alternates between Raphael’s sorrowful harmonica, Bobbie’s melodious piano, and Payne’s skillful guitar and mandolin solos. It has a feel of an old western movie’s closing credits, even though such a film didn’t exist then. However, it is best to appreciate the album as it stands, for although a film based on this theme came about ten years later with Willie himself starring in it, the music remains captivating on its own.

Initially, the country album titled “Red Headed Stranger” didn’t seem likely to become a success. Columbia executives were taken aback when they first listened to it, finding its raw, seemingly unpolished sound reminiscent of a demo recording. They felt as though it was hastily put together in a single take without any further refinement or professional mixing.

The sound was exactly as you heard it, for that’s exactly how it was initially played. Nelson and his band managed to record the entire piece in just one day. They spent a couple of additional days correcting obvious errors and balancing the mix, but Willie specifically requested that his vocals not be altered in any way.

As a music enthusiast, I aimed for an authentic, gritty vibe that didn’t quite align with either traditional or contemporary country styles. It definitely wasn’t the polished countrypolitan sound, and there were no violins or backup choirs accompanying it. Moreover, it wasn’t the rock-infused outlaw country Columbia Records might have anticipated.

To the executives’ dismay, there wasn’t a single standout success – merely a collection of songs that were too familiar to recall and some newly penned material by Nelson that felt more like interludes. What they missed was an old tune composed by Fred Rose, which had been a chart-topper nearly three decades ago.

What they missed was “Blue Eyes Crying in the Rain.”

Midway through Side One, a soft, sorrowful rendition of heartache emerges, centered around a wistful guitar melody and harmonica. Willie’s sincere, heartfelt performance resonated strongly. The tune gained traction on the radio, capturing the hearts of many listeners.

Prior to 1975, Willie Nelson hadn’t managed to top the country charts with a number one hit. However, that all changed when “Blue Eyes Crying in the Rain” was released. This song became the undisputed number one country tune of the entire year.

Additionally, it significantly achieved success by reaching number 21 on the pop charts, which was a first for Willie. However, this wasn’t his final appearance on the charts.

In a different phrasing, we can say: The Red Headed Stranger was full of untapped talent; another well-known tune, “Remember Me,” was equally successful. A stripped-down rendition of Jeannie Seely’s hit “Can I Sleep in Your Arms” showcased the Family’s ability to convey emotion powerfully with a minimalistic approach, veering towards gospel music. The song “Denver” is one of the most impactful short songs you’ll come across.

Columbia, with some hesitation, decided to publish the album titled “Red Headed Stranger” without much pomp. Willie, backed by his contract, believed otherwise; they anticipated that the album would fail, and that their star would revert to producing the kind of albums they preferred once again.

Instead of tanking, “Red Headed Stranger” reached the top of the country chart – a first for Willie. Previously, his two Atlantic albums had only managed to appear on the pop charts but never broke into the top 100. Surprisingly, “Red Headed Stranger” peaked at number 28. This was the beginning of Willie Nelson’s impressive run of 13 number-one country albums over the following years, along with a dozen more top ten entries.

In certain aspects, “Red Headed Stranger” can be likened to country music’s equivalent of Bruce Springsteen’s “Nebraska” in the realm of rock & roll. Both albums were characterized by minimalist production, with a speedy and cost-effective recording process. They both prioritized raw authenticity and strong songwriting over ornate effects and voluminous soundscapes.

In contrast to Nebraska, which significantly impacted numerous musicians across various musical styles, Red Headed Stranger achieved unprecedented success. This influence wasn’t confined solely to country artists; it extended to the decision-makers within the country music industry. In this way, it played a crucial role in shaping Willie Nelson’s career trajectory and the evolution of the entire country music genre.

Read More

2025-04-19 13:00