Danielle Deadwyler and evocative flashbacks hit the highest notes in The Piano Lesson

Danielle Deadwyler and evocative flashbacks hit the highest notes in The Piano Lesson

As a gamer who has spent countless hours immersed in virtual worlds, I can tell you that the most captivating experiences are those that transport us into rich, emotionally complex narratives. The latest adaptation of August Wilson’s “The Piano Lesson” certainly fits this description, offering a gripping portrayal of familial strife and the haunting weight of history.


The past never leaves us alone. It’s always lingering, like a shadow or rain cloud. Still, even with this reality, life does go on. Just as the members of the Charles family circa. 1936. Boy Willie Charles (John David Washington) has grand ambitions to buy up a pot of land that his family used to work on as slaves and servants. The thing is, though, he needs some money to make that purchase a reality. His idea is to go up to Pittsburgh with his associate Lymon (Ray Fisher) and sell his family’s piano. That costly heirloom is lingering in the living room of his sister Berniece Charles (Danielle Deadwyler), who hasn’t touched it since the family suffered a great tragedy.

In this home shared by Boy Willie Charles, Berniece, her daughter Maretha (Skylar Aleece Smith), and their uncle Doaker (Samuel L. Jackson), tension arises as Boy Willie attempts to take a piano. Berniece adamantly refuses to let it go. However, the siblings’ longstanding disagreements escalate into an argument. As their heated dispute lingers, a fresh concern surfaces: Berniece believes the spirit of James Sutter, a former white slaveowner who once owned her family, is haunting her home. The supernatural and emotional echoes of the past now cast a shadow over everyone within its walls.

In simpler terms, “The Piano Lesson” is a fresh movie version of an August Wilson play. Malcolm Washington, new to feature-length films, both directs and writes this adaptation with Virgil Williams. Unlike previous film adaptations of Wilson’s works like “Fences” and “Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom”, this one is helmed by a new director. However, much like its predecessors, “The Piano Lesson” excels at presenting talented actors with substantial dialogues. The elements that make great stage shows (which Wilson’s works certainly fit into) are also the most admirable qualities found in play adaptations such as “The Piano Lesson”.

Regarding the role, it is undoubtedly Danielle Deadwyler who shines brightest in “The Piano Lesson”. This isn’t unexpected given her rich background in Atlanta, Georgia theater and her powerful performance in the 2022 film “Till”. Yet, her talent in this production continues to amaze. Whenever Berniece takes center stage, Deadwyler captivates your focus effortlessly. There’s a particularly impactful scene where she rebukes the men around her, symbolizing a deep-rooted systemic issue. In Deadwyler’s portrayal, you can sense the weight of decades of pain in every word Berniece speaks.

In a subsequent part, the character Avery Brown (played by Corey Hawkins), a local preacher, makes an attempt at proposing to Berniece. This event, featuring Brown’s assertion that Berniece will find completeness with a man beside her, triggers a passionate monologue from Berniece about her self-image and aspirations. Deadwyler brings immense fervor to these performances. Moreover, a crucial, climactic scene heavily relies on Deadwyler’s capacity for delivering intense, deeply emotional lines. This trust in his abilities is proven to be well-placed. Despite being required to recite the same line multiple times, Deadwyler manages to maintain your focus.

In “The Piano Lesson,” multiple actors deliver commendable performances. However, it’s Danielle Deadwyler who truly shines with raw emotion within her character. Regarding the climactic scene centered on Berniece, this pivotal moment represents the effective application of horror film elements by Malcolm Washington. Similar to another 2020s play adaptation, “The Father,” “The Piano Lesson” employs terrifying cinematic visual techniques to provide a deeper understanding of its characters and offer audiences an unparalleled stage experience. Washington demonstrates great skill in handling such material. The final scene, in particular, is brilliantly executed, particularly in the strategic appearance and disappearance of certain apparitions throughout the shots.

The remainder of “The Piano Lesson” leans towards the functional rather than the extraordinary. For example, Alexandre Desplat’s score is one of his less complex compositions. It often seems to lack a distinct identity and might have been more imaginatively tied to the horror elements in “The Piano Lesson“. Fortunately, Wilson’s unique dialogue style holds its own, managing to offset the more routine aspects of this adaptation. A straightforward portrayal of his words delivered by skilled actors still makes for a reasonably intriguing viewing experience.

Samuel L. Jackson plays the character Doaker well, demonstrating his ability to excel in serious roles. It’s great to see him prove this talent again in this film. The main characters played by John David Washington and Ray Fisher are strong, but they aren’t as unique as Deadwyler in their acting styles. Washington’s deep Southern accent as Boy Willie Charles sometimes feels out of place given the movie’s focus on intimacy. This kind of powerful delivery would work well on stage, where actors often need to deliver big performances. However, in a film that aims for realism, Washington’s voice can occasionally clash with the more naturalistic performances. Despite this, he doesn’t hurt the movie and it’s nice to see Ray Fisher back in a major role.

In a characteristic fashion, Washington and cinematographer Mike Gioulakis imbue The Piano Lesson with a common visual style during dialog scenes. However, they delve deeper into unique instincts when the screen is flooded with sudden glimpses of the past. These outdoor sequences brilliantly capitalize on natural light and low-angle shots to evoke a dreamlike atmosphere for these flashbacks. The lighting and camera placement, particularly during Berniece’s remembrance of her late husband holding her by the river, are exceptionally poignant, underscoring why these Piano Lesson characters value those specific memories from their past so dearly.

In the play “The Piano Lesson,” setting up a visually unique divide between the past and present not only intensifies its contemplations on these timeframes, but also adds complexity. Each member of the cast has a unique perspective on dealing with the past in the current moment. While this exploration doesn’t lead to a revolutionary or structure-altering version of “The Piano Lesson” like Wilson’s original script, it does showcase Malcolm Washington’s directorial debut with creative visual elements and allows Danielle Deadwyler to further demonstrate her artistic abilities.

Read More

Sorry. No data so far.

2024-11-19 16:15