Outlander Book Club: The Scottish Prisoner Chapter 33 breakdown

by

Outlander Book Club: The Scottish Prisoner Chapter 33 breakdown

As a devoted fan of Diana Gabaldon and her captivating world, I must say that diving back into Lord John Grey’s tale in Chapter 33 of “The Scottish Prisoner” is always a delight. Having traversed through the intricate tapestry of the Outlander series multiple times, it feels like reuniting with an old friend.

We return to Hal’s residence for the continuation of “The Scottish Prisoner,” specifically Chapter 33. Here, Lord John Grey is in the process of recuperating following his near-death experience.

It’s evident that there was widespread concern about whether or not Lord John Grey would survive. Additionally, Edward Twelvetrees’ fate is a topic of interest as well, given that he met his end and Lord John Grey wasn’t held accountable. However, it remains puzzling why Lord John Grey, who was previously charged with the murder of Siverly, has yet to face repercussions for his escape from prison.

The chapter has some beautiful foreshadowing in it, as well. It connects well to the main Outlander books.

Breaking down The Scottish Prisoner Chapter 33

The chapter opens with Lord John Grey waking up. Many feared that he was dead, but he has pulled through. He does later think about how he’s grateful that Dr. Hunter wasn’t the one to work on him. He even empathizes with Quinn’s fear of being anatomized after death.

In this rephrased version, Lord John discovers the fate of Twelvetrees; unfortunately, he passed away, yet there’s no animosity towards John. Instead, people consider John as a brave soul who confronted Twelvetrees in a duel because they believed Twelvetrees was a traitor. Consequently, John earns accolades and numerous letters from admirers expressing their desire to wed him and produce his heirs. Indeed, such admiration seems warranted given both the social standing and prestige associated with his title.

In this particular section, we find John bonding with his nephews – Benjamin, Adam, and Henry. It offers us an insight into his affection for the young ones, and their admiration towards him is evident. However, there’s a somewhat awkward instance where John discusses his personal areas due to Adam’s inquiry, which might imply that he’s not very accustomed to interacting with children in such contexts.

As John receives letters from the women, he contemplates his unsuitability as a husband and his reluctance to father a child. Given what we know about the Outlander plot, John doesn’t have a biological son initially, but later does. It seems that this scenario may pave the way for John to marry Isabel and adopt Willie, thus providing him an opportunity to avoid other marriage proposals. Being a compassionate man, this arrangement appears to be a wise choice.

When John mentions that those letters could be destroyed, Minnie gently reminds him that one has a more professional tone. It’s penned by H. Bowles. John replies that even this one could be burned. Frankly, I find it surprising that Minnie hadn’t perused that letter, given she reads all the others. One would expect her curiosity to be piqued about why Bowles is corresponding with Lord John Grey.

Could this chapter be used in a TV adaptation?

To fully understand the sequence of events following the duel, it’s crucial that we include the chapter about “The Scottish Prisoner” in any adaptation. This is because it provides insights into John’s fate as well as the circumstances surrounding Twelvetrees and why John escapes arrest.

I’d be delighted to witness this moment with John and his nephews. Initially, it was unusual to think of John as a father since we rarely saw him around kids. Yet, this scene serves as a gentle reminder that he is indeed a compassionate man. There’s an undercurrent of nostalgia, a longing (yet also not) for him to have children of his own. The bittersweetness lies in his focus on what he can’t (and eventually doesn’t) desire.

Additionally, there’s a special “Minnie Moment” that features letters, which I always appreciate since Minnie is such a captivating figure in her own right.

Read More

2024-09-25 18:37