Outlander Book Club: Lord John and the Custom of the Army Section 5 breakdown

by

Outlander Book Club: Lord John and the Custom of the Army Section 5 breakdown

As a seasoned gamer and history enthusiast with a soft spot for well-crafted narratives, I must say that Section 5 of “Lord John and the Custom of the Army” is nothing short of a gripping tale. While I may not see the broader significance of the story as a whole, the Malcolm Stubbs segments are undeniably captivating.

Section 5 centers around a military engagement, during which Lord John Grey finds himself in a perilous situation where he risks his life to save another.

As a seasoned reader who has encountered countless stories, I must say that this chapter, while not entirely captivating me from start to finish, did pique my interest with its vivid portrayal of Lord John Grey in action. Being no stranger to historical fiction myself, I can appreciate the author’s efforts to remind us that our protagonist is indeed a soldier at heart. The intricacies and nuances of his character are beautifully showcased in this chapter, offering a refreshing perspective on a well-known figure from history.

In addition, we meet Simon Fraser, a character who seems to be identical to the one featured in the primary Outlander novels.

Breaking down Lord John and the Custom of the Army Section 5

Two weeks have passed since the last segment, and now the time for battle has arrived. While pondering over Hal’s remarks about Wolfe being overly dramatic, John finds himself in a situation where Wolfe loses his life due to his actions. Luckily, it wasn’t John who nearly met a similar fate.

In our storyline, we encounter Simon Fraser, a man who finds himself embroiled in the conflict due to his fluency in French. It’s interesting that there’s no mention of Fraser from John’s perspective, leading me to wonder if he might consider Jamie instead. This has left me questioning whether it’s the same Simon Fraser that Jamie encounters in ‘Written in My Own Heart’s Blood’, or perhaps it could be ‘An Echo in the Bone’. What I find intriguing is how Simon’s French language skills allow him to deceive the French sentry, making them believe they are part of the French Army.

In our narrative, much of the action is experienced through John’s perspective, giving us insights into his character as a soldier. It becomes apparent that he’s skilled in combat, a trait that aligns well with what we’ve learned about Crefeld. Yet, an unexpected moment arises when John encounters Malcolm Stubbs, who has lost his lower right leg. The sight of Malcolm wishing to die leaves John resolute, and he vehemently opposes this course of action.

In this scenario, a French soldier pursues John, but just when things seem dire, an English soldier intervenes and shields John from harm, thereby rescuing his life. This brave soldier, along with John, subsequently helps someone named Malcolm reach the medical personnel. Interestingly, it turns out that the heroic figure is none other than the dubious Silverley, demonstrating that a soldier labeled as ‘corrupt’ may still play a crucial role in saving lives during wartime.

Could this chapter be used in a TV series adaptation?

One reason for featuring “Lord John and the Custom of the Army” in a potential Lord John Grey series is its depiction of a significant battle, which transports us back to that era while providing ample drama. Additionally, it offers glimpses of Simon Fraser at a younger age and presents Lord John Grey in action. I can’t imagine this short story being overlooked if an adaptation were to take place.

If it were indeed the case, this chapter would prove essential. Beyond depicting conflict, it explains Malcolm Stubbs’ return to England, as his single leg renders him incapable of fighting. Furthermore, it sets up the significant scene with Siverley, a detail that is likely to impact Carruthers’ court martial proceedings.

Read More

2024-08-02 18:38